Ron Wyden: Richard Burr’s FISA reauthorization bill should be debated publicly

Tuesday, 24 October 2017, 10:32:54 PM. The Senate Intelligence Committee will debate legislation to reauthorize a controversial foreign surveillance law behind closed doors Tuesday — a decision that spawned protest from at least one lawmaker who says the bill should be publicly discussed.

The Senate Intelligence Committee will debate legislation to reauthorize a controversial foreign surveillance law behind closed doors Tuesday — a decision that spawned protest from at least one lawmaker who says the bill should be publicly discussed.

Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, which gives federal agencies their snooping powers, is set to expire at the end of the year without reauthorization from Congress and lawmakers are debating various proposals that could limit spy agencies surveillance authority.

The draft set for consideration Tuesday was authored by Sen. Richard Burr, the North Carolina Republican who heads the committee.

According to a draft version of the bill posted online Monday by the website Lawfare, the proposal would codify instances in which information incidentally collected about Americans could be used in criminal cases against them — such as cases related to national security; in instances involving death, kidnapping, serious bodily injury, and certain sex offenses against minors.

Section 702 allows authorities to collect and review emails, texts, and other communications of foreigners who are located outside the United States, but Americans’ communications can be incidentally swept up in surveillance of other targets. Investigators can later query the information collected as they investigate other matters — a tactic civil liberties advocates say amounts to a “backdoor” warrantless search of Americans’ information.

Sen. Burr’s proposal would reauthorize the law through 2025.

The draft version would also enable agencies to restart collection of communications that merely mention a particular foreign target, rather than communications directly to or from that target. The attorney general and director of national security would have to notify Congress if they intend to restart the so-called “about” collection and Congress would have to pass legislation within 30-days in order to block that collection from taking place.

The National Security Agency stopped using the controversial form of surveillance this year after privacy concerns were raised. The NSA reported that it had “discovered several inadvertent compliance lapses” that involved queries of Americans.

Sen. Ron Wyden acknowledged that some discussion of the bill might have to be done in private if classified matters are brought up, but he wrote to Mr. Burr on Monday to ask that the committee try to hold open hearings on Section 702.

“This legislation will have enormous impact on the security, liberty, and constitutional rights of the American people,” the Oregon Democrat wrote. “The public has therefore taken a keen interest in the outcome of this mark-up and in specific proposed reforms to Section 702.”

Civil liberties advocates have sought changes to Section 702 authority they say are needed to better protect Americans’ privacy and limit instances in which their communications can be scooped up and reviewed.

Neema Singh Guliani, legislative counsel with the American Civil Liberties Union, said Mr. Burr’s draft proposal does nothing to address concerns about the backdoor collection of Americans communications.

She noted that during past reauthorization debates, the House and Senate judiciary committees have held open hearings on Section 702 and held closed sessions to address any classified matters that may come up during debate.

“There is no need for an entirely closed mark up of this legislation, where the public has no real ability to hear the arguments and the positions that lawmakers take,” she said.

House lawmakers introduced reauthorization legislation earlier this month that advocates believe would rein in some of the objectionable practices. The proposal introduced by Rep. Bob Goodlatte and John Conyers Jr., the respective top Republican and Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee, would require investigators to ask a federal court for permission to use information collected under Section 702 in a criminal probe and it would end their ability to collect Americans’ communications with foreigners outside the U.S. based solely on the mention of a foreign surveillance target.

A competing Senate proposal from Mr. Wyden and Sen. Rand Paul, Kentucky Republican, is also expected to be introduced this week.

HIDE COMMENTS

blog comments powered by Disqus

Click to Read More

Click to Hide

Top Stories

**FILE** President Obama and Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg take off their jackets at Facebook headquarters in Palo Alto, Calif., on April 20, 2011, before their joint town-hall meeting to discuss reducing the federal deficit. (Associated Press)

How the liberal leanings of Google, Facebook shape the political landscape

"Sanctuary" status was a hot topic this summer in Massachusetts, where the Supreme Judicial Court ruled that state and local authorities could no longer legally hold immigrants for pickup by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. (Associated Press/File)

Illegal immigrant who paved way for Massachusetts’ ‘sanctuary’ policy arrested in stunning robbery

obj.0.content_object.caption

Quiz: US Citizenship Test - Could You Pass?

Maryland Attorney General Brian Frosh said it was unfair that accusations against Hillary Clinton's attorneys had become public even though they've yet to face charges. (Associated Press)

Maryland attorney general seeks to derail probe into Hillary Clinton’s lawyers

Hillary Clinton is accused of direct involvement in suspected corruption involving a 2010 uranium deal with Russia. (Associated Press/File)

FBI informant’s testimony sought as Clinton-Russia uranium case re-emerges

obj.0.content_object.caption

Quiz: Test Your Civil War Knowledge

ACLU rejects Christian baker’s free speech claim: ‘This is not about the cake’

Megyn Kelly poses on the set of her new show, "Megyn Kelly Today" at NBC Studios on Thursday, Sept, 21, 2017, in New York. Kelly says she complained to her bosses about Bill O'Reilly's behavior after she had accused former Fox chief Roger Ailes of sexual harassment, and that the abuse and shaming of women has to stop.Kelly, now with her own show on NBC, spoke Monday, Oct. 24, 2017, after it was revealed in The New York Times that Fox paid a $32 million settlement to former Fox analyst Lis Wiehl shortly before his contract was renewed. O'Reilly was fired in April. (Photo by Charles Sykes/Invision/AP) ** FILE **

O’Reilly shares Megyn Kelly’s ‘dear friend (no matter what you say)’ note after she rips Fox actions

Members of New Orleans Saints kneel before the national anthem before an NFL football game between the Green Bay Packers and the Saints, Sunday, Oct. 22, 2017, in Green Bay, Wis. (AP Photo/Jeffrey Phelps)

Trump blasts NFL players for ‘total disrespect’ after about two dozen refuse to stand for flag

U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions speaks at the International Association of Chiefs of Police conference Monday, Oct. 23, 2017, in Philadelphia. Sessions on Monday designated the gang, MS-13, as a priority for a federal task force that traditionally pursued cartels and drug kingpins. (AP Photo/Michael Balsamo)

Sessions unleashes organized crime task force on MS-13

ap090421032401_primary_image.jpg

Conservatives in Hollywood: Celebrities who lean right

TV personality Katie Couric attends the premiere of "Makers: Women Who Make America" at Alice Tully Hall at Lincoln Center in New York on Feb. 6, 2013. (AP Photo/Starpix, Marion Curtis) ** FILE **

Katie Couric says ‘neo-Nazi’ threat causing insomnia

Teenagers who used e-cigarettes with higher concentration levels of nicotine were more likely to report an increased frequency of vaping and greater levels of smoking cigarettes, a study found. (Associated Press/File)

High-nicotine e-cigarettes linked to more harmful smoking habits among youths

converted 1911.jpg

21 best guns for home protection

NBC'S Megyn Kelly told viewers on Oct. 23, 2017, that she complained about Bill O'Reilly's behavior in November 2016. (Image: Twitter, NBC screenshot)

Megyn Kelly rips O’Reilly, says she emailed top brass over behavior: ‘I complained’

Andrew Weissmann (right) and Kyle Freeny (center) are members of special counsel Robert Mueller's team of prosecutors investigating potential ties between Russia and Donald Trump's 2016 presidential campaign. (Associated Press/File)

Mueller’s top gun in Russia probe known for hardball tactics, overturned rulings

AP26539704575

Christians in Hollywood

In this July 28, 2017, file photo, House Intelligence Committee Chairman Rep. Devin Nunes, R-Calif., walks on Capitol Hill in Washington. A political research firm behind a dossier of allegations about President Donald Trump's connections to Russia is balking at subpoenas from the House intelligence committee, with a lawyer for the firm questioning the legitimacy of the panel's probe into Russian meddling. Joshua Levy, a lawyer for Fusion GPS, said in a letter to the panel on Oct. 16 that Nunes is acting "in bad faith." (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File)

Judge to decide if House committee has access to Fusion GPS bank records

Newsletters

  •  Daily
  •  Weekly
  •  Pruden on Politics
  •  Charles Hurt

Find us on Facebook

Find us on Twitter

All site contents © Copyright 2017 The Washington Times, LLC|3600 New York Avenue NE | Washington, DC 20002 |202-636-3000
...Read more
Share this

You might also like

Similar